Manchester By The Sea is out right now in limited release. If you can find it, I urge you to go see this incredible film. I saw this film in January at Sundance going in knowing next to nothing. All there was in the program was this picture of Kyle Chandler and Casey Affleck who play brothers in the film. And the name Kenneth Lonergan, the writer director. That’s the name that made this film a must see for me. He has only written and directed three films. His first feature, You Can Count On Me gave us an incredible debut by Mark Ruffalo as Laura Linney’s ne’er do well brother. His second film, Margaret, starring Anna Paquin, was finally released on DVD recently.
This is the short review of Manchester By The Sea I wrote on Letterboxd after I returned from Sundance:
Casey Affleck plays a janitor who has to return to his hometown when his brother (Kyle Chandler) suddenly dies of a heart attack. He’s named guardian for his teenage nephew, and you come to understand through flashbacks why he is so reluctant to assume that role. Michelle Williams plays his ex-wife, in a fantastic supporting role. Lucas Hedges is the 16 year old nephew, and he is amazing. This is a break out role for this young actor.
But Casey Affleck’s melancholy superb acting had me sobbing, not just tears down my face but holding my hand over my mouth to keep quiet in the theater sobbing. This is a masterful movie about real people and their grief.
If you can, go see this film without watching the trailer, because the trailer shows part of a key scene between Casey Affleck and his ex-wife, Michelle Williams. I think it has more impact if you don’t know what’s coming.
Casey Affleck is a lock for a best actor Oscar nomination, and Manchester By The Sea is at the top of best of 2016 film lists, right after La La Land. I haven’t seen La La Land yet (Dec. 9th can’t come fast enough), but Manchester By The Sea is the best film I’ve seen so far this year.
It’s difficult for me to name just one film as my favorite from this year, because there were several standouts for me. For my full list with reviews, here is my Letterboxd list for Sundance 2016
Captain Fantastic — “Deep in the forests of the Pacific Northwest, a father (Viggo Mortensen) devoted to raising his six kids with a rigorous physical and intellectual education is forced to leave his paradise and re-enter society, beginning a journey that challenges his idea of what it means to be a parent.” Viggo is AMAZING in this film as an extreme home schooling dad, in probably my favorite film. I can’t think of anyone else more perfect for this role. The young actor who plays the oldest son is also incredible. A ★★★★½ review of Captain Fantastic (2016)
2. Manchester By The Sea – Kenneth Lonnergan’s film stars Casey Affleck and Michelle Wiliams. Affleck has to return to his home town Manchester By The Sea when a family member suddenly dies. You gradually learn why he is so reluctant to be the guardian for his 16 year old nephew. Searing film that we will be seeing come Oscar time, to be sure. Five stars!! Lucas Hedges is great as the young nephew, but Casey Affleck’s melancholy superb acting had me sobbing — not just tears down my face but holding my hand over my mouth to keep quiet in the theater sobbing. This is a masterful movie about real people and their grief. A ★★★★★ review of Manchester by the Sea (2016)
3. The Birth Of A Nation – Nate Parker’s slave drama about Nat Turner’s revolt in 1831 deservedly was the most talked about film at the festival. It won the audience and grand jury prize. I expect it to win Best Picture at the Oscars. Just an incredible film. Nate Parker choked up with tears at our screening talking about how hard it was to get his film made, and it received standing ovation after standing ovation at the fest. A ★★★★★ review of The Birth of a Nation (2016)
4. Ali and Nino – I LOVED this sweeping romantic epic set in WWI era Azerbaijan. Ali is a Muslim prince who falls for the aristocratic Christian Nino. Mandy Patinkin plays Nino’s father. The director, Asif Kapadia, just won the Oscar for his documentary film Amy, and I loved previous Sundance doc Senna. So glad to see a new narrative feature from him. A ★★★★★ review of Ali & Nino (2016)
5. Hunt for The WilderpeopleA hilarious comic romp by director Taika Waititi. (I have great hopes for the next Thor movie after seeing this movie, and laughing through Taika MCing the Sundance award night.) Sam Neill is more curmudgeonly than ever, and has a fantastic reluctant relationship with his foster son played by newcomer Julian Dennison. The film is out in New Zealand already, so you can see for yourself in the trailer below:
6. Other People – A gay writer son comes home to help take care of his mother when she is diagnosed with cancer. Molly Shannon is the mother, and you’ve never seen her like this. She’s fantastic.
7. Green Room – Patrick Stewart as the villainous owner of a Neo-Nazi punk rock club. I don’t need to say anything more. Anton Yelchin and his punk band have to escape a green room at the club after they witness a murder. There’s a trailer already for this incredibly intense thriller.
Now we get down in the list to films that were good, but not my favorites.
8. Belgica – Two brothers run a hip nightclub in Belgium. Predictable what happens, but the music was particularly good on the soundtrack. Many parallels to the refugee crisis.
9. Morris From America – Craig Robinson and his son, played by Markees Christmas are the only black people in their entire German town. Markees young 13 year old character loves rap and is incredibly sweet.
10. Southside With You – This is the story of Barack Obama and Michelle’s first date when she was his mentor at his summer job at the law firm, Sidley Austin in Chicago (my husband’s firm.) I really liked this film, even if you couldn’t even tell it was filmed in Chicago.
11. Sand Storm – set in a Bedouin village in Israel. Everything changes when the father in this family drama decides to marry a second wife. Really compelling story, with a debut Israeli director. This clip shows the moment the first wife must welcome the second bride:
12. Halal Love – Four tragicomic interconnected stories about how devoted Muslim men and women are trying to manage their love life and desires without breaking any religious rules. This film set in Lebanon was really entertaining and super interesting. I did not know before this film about “temporary” halal marriages.
13. Brahman NamanA raunchy sex comedy set in the ’80s in Bangalore. The film is in English and is sort of an Indian American Pie. Naman and his friends are all on their college quiz team, which evidently was a huge thing. Was not expecting an Indian movie where the opening scene has Naman masturbating in the door of a fridge!
14. Mapplethorpe: Look At the PicturesThis fascinating documentary just started airing on HBO this week. I really didn’t know that much about him, other than remembering Jesse Helms ranting about him in the ’80s.
15. Holy Hell was an amazing documentary filmed inside a cult. The director was the official videographer of the cult for years, and had incredible footage. The Q&A with several former members of the cult who were in the documentary was particularly powerful.
16. Life Animated – moving documentary about a family with an autistic son, who they finally are able to reach through his love of Disney animated movies.
And now the disappointing films on the list.
17. Love and Friendship – Based on an unfinished novel by Jane Austen. Had some really hilarious zinger lines, and it was very fun to see Chloe Sevigny and Kate Beckinsale in this movie. But it dragged and could have used tighter editing. Hopefully they tightened it up for theatrical release.
18. Certain Women – Three stories of women in the modern AmericanWest. Performances were great, especially the acting of the Native American lonely rancher (Lily Gladstone). But oh, my, god was this movie like watching grass grow. So slow.
19. Yoga Hosers – Midnight movie starring Kevin Smith and Johnny Depp’s daughters as clerks of a Canadian convenience store. It was worth seeing just to see Kevin Smith choke up talking about coming back to Sundance with this movie. It was amusing and silly, but Brat Nazis? Really?
20. Jaqueline (Argentine) – decidedly quirky doc film within a film. I fell asleep during it to be honest.
21. Swiss Army Man – I have NEVER seen so many people walk out of a movie at Sundance! People in the 4th row walked out 1/2 an hour in! This was my 23 year old son’s favorite movie, and my husband hated it. But it’s like a train wreck that you can’t help but watch. Daniel Radcliffe is a farting corpse that Paul Dano rides like a jet ski to escape a deserted island. And that’s just the first 10 minutes. The trailer just came out, so you can see for yourself with this truly bizarre film. I shouted “WHAT?!!!” when “The Daniels” won the jury prize for directing at Sundance.
But Swiss Army Man is a screening I will NEVER forget. It was worth it just to say I was there!
22. Christine – Rebecca Hall plays Christine Chubbock, a Tampa TV reporter who committed suicide on air. The acting was very good, but again, the tempo of the film was slow for me.